Magnetic Resonance Imaging in Focal Onset Epilepsy
by Charles B. Gover, M.D.
For
more than 100 years, a cause-and-effect relationship between pathologic
alterations in brain structure and seizure has been recognized.
The precise mechanism by which seizures are produced is unknown;
the association between structural pathology and focal onset seizures
originating in or near the lesion is well accepted. This article
focuses predominately on the magnetic resonance (MR) appearance
of the known histologic substrates of recurrent seizures in patients
with symptomatic focal onset epileptic syndromes. The use of computed
tomography (CT) in epilepsy is not reviewed in this article. The
properties of MR imaging (superior soft tissue contrast, multi-
planar imaging, and lack of beam hardening artifacts) virtually
allow detection of all pathologic abnormalities with greater sensitivity
and accuracy than with CT. Thus, while epileptogenic lesions are
visible by CT, the advantages of MR imaging are more pronounced
for pathological conditions such as focal cortical dysplasia/migrational
anomalies and mesial temporal sclerosis MTS).
The
Role of MR Imaging in Epilepsy
MR imaging plays several important and distinct roles in clinical
management of patients with epilepsy. The most important is to locate
and identify the epileptogenic lesion of partial onset seizures.
By ascertaining the location and characteristics of an epileptogenic
abnormality via MR imaging, it can be determined if surgical resection
is feasible. Important information can be obtained such as the volume
of tissue targeted for resection, the surgical approach, and the
relationship of the lesion with regard to functionally important
brain areas.
It
can also help re-classify seizure type if a lesion is detected in
patients with generalized seizures. For example, partial onset seizures
that secondarily generalize rapidly can be misinterpreted as primarily
generalized. Additionally, it can provide useful prognostic information
following surgery. Certain lesions identified on MR imaging carry
a favorable prognosis (e.g., MTS or cavernous angioma); but post-surgical
patients with no lesion on MR imaging or with neutronal migrational
abnormalities carry a poor prognosis.
Epiliptogenic
Lesuib and Seizure Production
The concept that brain lesions produce seizure is regarded to be
true. The precise mechanism by which brain lesions produce seizures
is not that clear. It is presumed that seizures arise from neurons
that lie adjacent to a lesion that is rendered by several possible
mechanisms susceptible to spontaneous coherent discharge. Mechanisms
that have been implicated include dis-function of the sodium/potassium
ion pump, changes in N-methyl-D-aspartic acid receptor channels,
abnormal regulation of gamma amino butyric acid (GABA), and abnormal
glial calcium ion transport. An exception to the general lack of
understanding of the seizure mechanism is MTS. It has been postulated
by animal studies that synaptic reorganization in the dentate hilus
of the hippocampus which creates abnormal intrinsic synchronous
excitatory circuitry is a basic feature of MTS.
Tumors
in Epilepsy
The histology and MR imaging features are different in patients
with acute or chronic seizure presentation.
Acute
Presentation
Tumors in acute seizure are primary or metastatic and are often
high grade. Although all ages are represented, the older patient
is generally affected. Typically a neurologic deficit is the most
serious manifestation of the disease; seizures are of secondary
importance. Complete resection is usually not performed when tumors
are present; they are usually biopsied and treated with radiation
or chemotherapy. On MR imaging tumors tend to be large, poorly demarcated
from surrounding normal brain, and tend to enhance; and peritumoral
edema and central necrosis are common with unusual calvarial remodeling.
Chronic
Presentation
Only primary low grade tumors are found (not metastatic). Tumors
are supratentorial and of glial or both glial and neuronal cell
orgin. An associated neurologic deficit is usually not present.
Patients are usually pediatric, young adults, or middle-aged. Surgical
strategy is aimed at complete lesion removal. Typical tumor histologies
are astrocytoma, oligodendroglioma, mixed oligodendroglial-astrocytic,
dysembrioplastic neuroepithelial tumors, ganglioglioma, and hamartoma.
On MR imaging, tumors tend to be small and well circumscribed, have
little or no periturmoral edema, commonly remodel the inner table
of the skull, have variable enhancement, usually cortical, typically
lack central neorosis, and are supra tentorial extra ventricular
(Figure 1).
|
Figure
1. Low grade astrocytoma - Sagittal T1WI (s) and
axial T2WI (b) demonstrate a right parietal cortical tumor hypointense
on T1WI and hyperintense on T2WI. There is remodeling of the
inner table of the parietal bone and no white matter edema. |
|
|
Neuronal
Migration Disorders
The spectrum of gray matter developmental abnormalities ranges from
widespread gross deformities such as lissencephaly to small focal
nodular gray matter heterotopias (Figure 2), and all are due to
defects in neuronal migration and organization that occur in utero.
These include gray matter migration abnormalities of the cortical
mantle or cortical dysplasias (agyria, pachygyria, and polymicrogyria),
abnormal location of gray matter or heterotopia (band, laminar,
or nodular), schizenencephaly (Figure 3), and hemimegalencephaly.
It is the focal cortical dysplasias that are most often considered
for surgical resection. The cerebral cortex is normally four millimeters
thick; and cortical dysplasias appear as areas of thickened cortex,
regardless of histologic description.
|
Figure
2. Nodular subependymal heterotopic gray matter nicely
seen on sagittal T1WI and axial T2WI. (arrows) |
|
|
Tuberous
sclerosis (TS) is a phakomatosis syndrome characterized by papular
facial nevus, seizure, and mental retardation (Figure 4). This triad
is found only in 50% of patients. Hence the radiologic hallmarks
of the disorder are very important and are now universally accepted
as sufficient for diagnosis. The four major categories of intracranial
lesions in TS are cortical tubers, white matter abnormalities, subependimal
nodules, and giant cell astrocytoma. The defect in TS appears to
be an abnormality in the radial neuron-glial unit in certain portions
of the germinal matrix. Cortical tubers have been classified both
as tumors and neuronal migration disorders. The appearance of cortical
tubers on MR images is characteristic; it consists of a well-circumscribed
area of increased T2 and decreased T1 signal intensity located immediately
beneath the cortical gray mantel. Typically the involved gyrus is
expanded. A ray-like projection of increased signal intensity from
the base of the cortical tuber toward the ventricular surface is
frequently observed.
Figure
3. Schizencephaly with cortical dysplasia - Sagittal T1WI (a)
and axial T2WI (b) shows two left schizencephalic clefts in the
frontal and parental lobes lined by abnormally thick gray matter.
In additon, there is bilateral abnormal cortical thickening of the
frontal-parietal lobes (cortical dysplasia). (arrows)
Figure
4. Sturge Weber Syndrome - Coronal (a) and axial (b)
postcontrast MR scans show atrophy of the left hemisphere. The pial
leptomeningeal anioma enhances strongly.
Vascular
Malformation
In a manner similar to tumors, vascular malformations that are found
in surgical epilepsy series are small, indolent lesions. These typically
are the cryptic malformations, that is, capillary angiomas or cavernous
angiomas. Arterio-venous malformations (AVM) can also present with
seizures; however, they commonly present with acute hemorrhage.
Sturge-Weber
disease is a phakomatosis syndrome characterized by facial, leptomeningeal,
and ocular angiomatosis, mental retardation, and neurologic deficits
that depend on the location of the leptomeningeal angioma (Figure
5). It is mentioned here because of the central role seizures have
in the clinical manifestation of the disease. The intracranial hallmark
is a pial angioma that is believed to represent persistent embryonic
vasculature. Seizures are believed to occur because of the effects
of this vascular malformation on the underlying brain. The MR imaging
features of the syndrome include enhancement of the pial angioma
and atrophy of the underlying cortex. The malformation is usually
unilateral and located in the parietal-occipital region; and the
ipsilateral choroid plexus enhances prominently.
Figure
5. Tuberours Sclerosis - Coronal T1WI (a) demonstrate
straight radial bands of increased signal intensity in the right
frontal lobe. Coronal T2WI (b) domonstrate right upper convexity,
subcortical tubers and small subependymal nodules in the atria of
the lateral ventricles. Axial T2WI (c) show bilateral frontal-parietal
subcortical increased signal consistent with subcortical tubers.
The one in the left parietal lobe with decreased signal is calcified.
(arrows)
MTS
The origin of MTS remains obscure. It is felt by many to be due
to complicated febrile convulsions that occur during a specific
window in early childhood (about three months to five years of age).
Calcium mediated excitotoxic cell injury is believed to be the primary
noxious event that leads to this condition. MTS consists of cell
loss and astrogliosis in the mesial temporal cortex, the hippocampal
formation, amygdala, parahippocampal gyrus, and entorhinal cortex.
These changes have been described in the hippocampus. Classic (Ammon's
horn) sclerosis consists of marked pyramidal cell loss in CA1, CA3,
and the dentate hilus with sparing of pyramidal cells in the CA2
sector. A second form known as end folium sclerosis consists primarily
of cell loss and astroglial proliferation in the end folium with
relative sparing of the other sectors.
Findings
on MR imaging include hippocampal atrophy, increased signal intensity
on T2 weighted images, loss of normal internal architecture of the
involved hippocampus, and unilateral atrophy of the mammillary body,
columns of fornix, amygdala, and white matter of the parahippocampal
gyrus (Figure 6). Autopsy studies have demonstrated that MTS is
present bilaterally in up to 80% of cases. However, it is usually
asymmetric in that one side is more severely involved or the two
hippocampi typically involve the site of origin of a patient's seizures.
|
Figure
6. Mesial Temporal Sclerosis - Oblique coronal inversion
recovery (a) demonstrate bilateral hippocampal atrophy more
prominent in the left side. Oblique coronal T2WI (b) show bilateral
increased signal intensity of both hippocampi and left temporal
lobe cortex. (arrows) |
|
|
|
Figure
7. Chronic cerebral infarction in a patient with
sickle cell with seizures since infarct - Coronal T1WI and axial
T2WI demonstrate evidence of a right frontal lobe volume loss
with cortical thinning with compensatory right lateral ventricular
dilation. |
|
|
Encephalmmalacia
or Gliosis
Cortical gliosis or scar can occur following any brain insult (trauma,
infarction, infection, and/or inflammation). Any of those four mechanisms
can produce an area of brain necrosis in which death of all cell
lines has occurred. Necrosis is typically surrounded, however, by
an area of sclerosis. Scelosis regardless of the causal mechanism,
has a common MR appearance (atrophy and signal change consistent
with increased tissue water).
Epilepsy
following head trauma is more frequent with missile injuries which
penetrate the skull than with closed head injuries, particularly
if they involve penetration of the dura. In cases of trauma hemosiderin
deposition in atrophic cortical tissue often occurs.
Cerebral
infarction is the most common etiology of new onset epilepsy in
the elderly (Figure 7). At the other end of the age spectrum, perinatal
or neonatal vascular insults may produce areas of cerebral infarction
associated with seizures. Mechanisms of infarction in this age group
are diverse: embolic, secondary to infection, trauma, hypoxia, and
hemorrhage.
On
a world-wide scale, infection is a much more common substrate of
epilepsy than in North America and Europe. In areas where cysticercosis
is endemic, a significant percentage of the population may be infected;
and seizures are the most clinical manifestation of neurocysticercosis
(Figure 8).
|
Figure
8. Nuerocysticercosis (colloidal vesicular stage)
- Coronal postcontrast T1WI (a) demonstrates a left lateral
frontal ring-like enhancing lesion. On T2WI (b) it shows thick
hypointense capsule with peripheral white matter edema.
|
|
|
References
Jack CR Jr. Epilepsy: surgery and imaging (state of the art). Radiology.
1993;189:635-646.
Jack
CR Jr. Magnetic resonance imaging neuroimaging and anatomy. Epilepsy.
1995;54:597-622.
Osborn
AG. Diagnostic Neuroradiology. Mosby Yearbook: St. Louis,
MO; 1994.
Barkovich
AJ. New York, NY: Raven Press;
1995.
Bruton
CJ. The Neuropathology of Temporal Lobe Epilepsy. Oxford,
UK: Oxford University Press; 1988.
Bronen
RA, Cheung G, Charles JT, et al. Imaging findings in hippocampal
sclerosis: correlation with pathology. Am J Neuroradial.
1991;12:933-940.
Kuzniecky
RI, Jackson GD. Magnetic Resonance in Epilepsy. New York,
NY: Raven Press; 1995.
Jackson
GD, Berkovic SF, Duncan JS, Connelly A. Optimizing the diagnosis
of hippocampal sclerosis using mr imaging. Am J Neuroradial.
1993;14:753-762.
Charles
B. Gover, M.D., is a board certified diagnostic radiologist who
practices with Radiology Associates in Corpus Christi and is a member
of the Nueces County Medical Society.
Copyright
© 2001 Radiology Associates.
|